the death of magic
Recently, a well known worship leader/Christian influencer suffered an unimaginable loss. Her 2 year old daughter Olive didn’t wake up. Her parents found her in the house not breathing, doctors pronounced her dead. I am so sorry for their loss, and I know a little bit about it. When I was in 3rd grade, my brother and I woke up to my mom screaming. In my childhood brain, my first reaction was to think we were in trouble of some kind. As we came into the living room, we saw that our sister Abigail was unresponsive on the floor. I don’t remember seeing her face, maybe it was obscured by my mom. I do remember seeing the tall EMS workers walk in in boots and carry her out in a hurry, and for a couple terrible moments being left alone in the house. This was a terrible decision for my mom to have to make but I think she made the right one. Ride in the EMS with your unresponsive child and leave your two startled children at home. Lucky for us, my mom called my sister who hauled ass and got to us very quickly.
All that was afterthoughts. All I remember in that moment was being in the living room with my brother and praying that god would bring her back. Then I fell asleep. The next thing I remember was my sister’s voice. She was going through a rolodex of names, telling people that my sister had died.
Strangely, at that time, I developed a terrible terrible fever. It made the nightmare of what was happening even more surreal. Maybe that was for the best.
The blur stretched on for days. Family and friends coming to town, big spreads of food on the dining room table, then the wake. Wake’s are always the same. The feeling of dress shoes on thick carpet, too much flower smell, people trying to small talk under an anvil that hangs over everyone. Family drama, people being upset with each other, I remember weird karate people coming to show respect. Maybe this is an exaggeration or a false memory, but I could have sworn someone came wearing a gi. Maybe I made that up.
The funeral, riding there in the car with my aunt who smoked in the back of the mortuary limo, making me think I was gonna be sick. The tombstone, the ride back home, then the long silence of life as life returns to 0.
I’ve never lost a child but I understand.
The story of the worship leader that I started with has a very macabre and upsetting problem. The well meaning but misguided family, extended church family and leaders in Bethel church are currently praying for the deceased child to be resurrected. To the average non religious and even the average religious person, this is insane. And you’re right. But to people who believe in miracles, and a god that intervenes, its not that weird.
Even in churches that don’t have practices like this, there are often times guest ministers, usually from countries that have more gullible believers in them, that claim they have raised people from the dead through the power of Jesus and prayer.
As creepy as this behavior is to some, I understand personally the internal logic of it.
You sing and pray and write and minister your whole life about a god who does wonders, now you are in need of a wonder.
I understand this because something similar happened to me.
When someone dies, families either assemble or they explode. In the wake of my dear older brother Bradley’s passing, the family exploded.
I remember getting the call in the middle of the night that he had fallen over during a basketball game at St. Andrews and was unresponsive. And my mom was once again reliving the nightmare of a child being whisked away in an ambulance.
When they say he passed out, I started praying but I wasn’t worried. I didn’t even get out of bed. Bradley was the strongest person I knew and very religious himself. He would be fine.
Another call, now he is unconscious and not responding. I got worried. I got out of bed in my tiny Copenhagen apartment and laid on my face in the floor and prayed for God to bring him back to his body.
Another call, he's dead. My mom and sister and other family in some hospital room with him. My mom pleading with me to call him back into his body. I screamed.
He was gone, and it rang in my ears like a gun fired near my head. My whole conception of the world had been stabbed. But being a man of faith at the time, I still got on my knees and prayed a paraphrased version of the prayer Job prayed when god brought calamity on him “the lord gives, and the lord takes away, blessed be the name of the Lord”.
I started booking plane tickets. It was $4000 dollars. My card got declined, not because I didn’t have it, I had just come from a big work trip and was essentially going to spend all my money on this trip. But the bank thought my account had got hacked. I had to borrow the money from my wife’s family.
And thus started a demoralizing process. The big loss was one thing, but the 100 little losses in moments like this are what broke me.
I could understand in concept that tragedy exists, how could I not. But the tiny injustices were seamingly never ending. I had just started Jiu Jitsu a month before, and the night he died I had hurt my neck so bad I couldn’t turn it. I had to fly for 18 hours in terrible discomfort, anxious to get home and my mind trying to make sense of this.
My only thought at that time was to get to my brothers widow. She wasn’t a stable woman at the best of times and we had had a falling out as I got older, but I felt like as Bradley’s brother her well being was my responsibility. I thought of all kinds of crazy scenarios. Paying for her to live with us until things settled down.
I didn’t know what to do.
I landed in America, and trouble had already been boiling. A legal battle was being staged for my brother’s body. On one side, my dad who was traveling back form Thailand, on the other side, my sister in law who wanted to remove his body so she could pray for him with her bible study group to bring him back.
I understood both sides. I was fiercely protective of my bother. But I also believed in miracles myself. And even in my heart I thought he was gone, he wouldn’t feel gone til I saw his body.
I called my brother’s widow as soon as I landed. I expected her to be in terrible grief. The first thing she said to me was “Joe..Joe..you got to be on my side on this one Joe..”. And it turned my stomach and broke my heart.
I knew in her tone that things were not good. Next, a voice came on the phone, some weird bitch from her bible study who had the audacity to talk to me in a chipper call center friendly tone. Telling me that they were there praying for Bradley to wake up.
This tension would go on for weeks. Actual weeks. In one camp, my dad, brother, and others trying to get legal access to Bradley’s remains so he could be buried. On the other, my brother’s unhinged widow trying to hold meetings in their John’s Island house for him to be resurrected.
In the middle, most of the reasonable members of my family. Trying to make everyone behave.
It was the most chaotic thing I have ever lived through and I hope it never happens again.
I’ll never forget going over to see my brother’s widow with my wife. I was hoping to bridge the gap, help her come to face the loss of him. The mental unhealth in the room was like a fever. Imagine having the worst day of your life, and going to people who are willing themselves to believe it is not happening. It was eery.
After a long, bitter, nasty process, we eventually buried him. To this day, I feel empathy for my sister-in-law. She was doing what she thought a good person should do.
But underneath this belief, was someone who was desperately and at all human cost avoiding reality. I don’t blame the other people in my family who started the legal battle. They were trying to protect Bradley’s memory. That is an honorable thing. One member of my family wanted the autopsy done right away so we could see if the heart defect he died from was possibly present in us as well. I understand that too.
At the end, it felt like everyone was killing each other to save something that was long gone.
I’ve never told this story publicly, but I think its the right time.
I’m sure my memory of this is subjective as are all memories. Honestly, I am more and more interested in having a truce with the past.
But I share this because its surreal to see someone else living this.
A network of people, spending hours with their eyes closed, trying to will themselves into a place of certainty. Trying to overcome to million pound weight of how the world works.
I wish kids came back from the dead healthy and sound. I wish people didn’t have to suffer.
I used to believe in magic. I used to believe in the impossible disappearing and appearing through the power of faith. But once life marks you with its dark lottery, you can’t un-see it.
I hope these people do right by this family and help them grieve properly by burying this child and honoring her short life.
If there is anything after this, I’d like to think kids like her, like my sister, and good souls like my brother have something to look forward to. Some great wind to blend into. Thats the best anyone can hope for.